Betty pulls her mother from the tub and performs CPR. Alice bumps into Hermione as she exits the office. They must find the chalices, flip the gryphon coin for their fate and drink from the chalice to meet their destiny. At the breakfast table, FP tells Alice that the Muggses received a tape and Alice replies that she will go to interview them for the tonight's broadcast. However, those things belong to the past and Betty is letting them crushing her. Betty and Betty rushes to the Farm’s compound to inform her mother of her father's return. Given that he just finished his last book, Betty wonders why he would kill himself if he was so close to being done. When Alice found out about the two, she was furious and tried to break them up. Alice asked if she could say goodbye to the twins and, after getting permission from her daughter, left the room. At the homecoming dance, she told him about the pregnancy, which leads to a big fight between the two, as Hal wanted Alice to abort the baby while Alice wanted to deliver it. Get it now! It is a trauma to leave the comfort of their wombs. Just as Alice questions the whereabouts of Penelope, she horrifically screams, gaining the rest of the Midnight Club’s attention. Mrs. Chipping reveals that he had a drinking problem, among other issues.

When Betty said she was, Alice was relieved because she knew very well how alluring and convincing the A couple of days later at the Jones' trailer, Alice scolded both Betty and Jughead for asking In the evening, Alice was washing dishes when Betty told her to sign a document for permission to get a tattoo since she was "basically, a member of the With shaking hands, Alice served tea while Darla made veiled threats, saying it was not the first time that Dwayne borrowed her car, but it was very strange that it had ended up in a swamp in Riverdale. When Penelope exclaims that they’re not going to the cops, Alice questions why she suddenly wants to break the rules, perhaps because she’s the killer. She calls Hal out for being a sinner and questions what Fred could've possibly done that would call for his death. From that point on, when the Midnight Club passed each other in the halls, they didn’t so much as smile. Together they have two children, son Sylvester Time Amick-Alexis (born July 5, 1992) and daughter Mina Tobias (born September 2, 1993). As Betty goes to burn the final book, Alice advises her to save it as they’re her precious childhood memories.At the Jones-Cooper house, Betty e Jughead informs FP and Alice about Mr. Honey's tyranny and claiming that he’s doing it out of spite. Despite FP covered her with his jacket, and distracted bystanders' attention with a speech, Alice left the bar after trying in vain to take Betty with her. Betty concludes that he hides his collection elsewhere as she can’t find it in the room. This, Alice believed, it's biblical punishment. Alice wondered what else Archie might have come across while in the sticky-red thick of it, anything about the board, she asked. Alice and Hal immediately rushed to medicate his wound. Three weeks have passed since the secret meeting and the horrible deaths of Alice argues with Betty over sharing family's secretsSome time later in Betty's room, Alice and Betty are arguing about what happened shortly before downstairs. While the others are partying non-stop, she finds herself taken back. Later, she visited FP at his trailer. Betty has a lot more questions to ask, which concerns Alice because the more you talk about the game, the more you think of it and the more at risk you are. Once joined by Jughead, Alice said she wasn't able to convince Betty to dress appropriately and then asked Tequila to the barman. Hal explains that Fred was an adulterer. Fortunately, she manages to revive Alice. Alice is a very protective parent when it comes to her family, especially to Betty, whom she was quite over-protective of when she found out that Polly was with child.

Some time later, Alice and the other former members of the Midnight Club heads down into the Betty then asks about Ascension Night, wondering if Norton was present. However, they do have one thing in common, they are both part of two of the wealthiest families in Riverdale. When Betty enters the room, Alice explains to her that she should burn them for her own good because she's been filling the page with so much pain and suffering over the years. Betty then asked where the baby would sleep and Alice claimed that Polly had decided to give the child up for adoption, unaware that Betty had previously talked with Polly about just that and knew her sister wanted to keep her child.After unexpectedly taking Hermione's advice, Alice decided to attend the baby shower, she and Polly hugged after professing how happy she was that Polly and the baby were safe. Alice claims she respect that and that she's not denying Betty's past. Alice agreed but said that for things to work this time there shouldn't be secrets. Before starting, to make things more enjoyable, Hiram takes a new drug known as fizzle rocks.